Mondays with MacDonald (cf. Tony Jones’ challenge)

by Steve Douglas

August 13th, 2012 | 3 Comments

Please understand: far be it from me to throw George MacDonald’s hat into the ring of progressive bibliobloggers, although his theology is often considered “liberal” by stalwart conservatives. Rather, let his words below in my own “handwriting” serve as my contribution to Tony Jones’ challenge to “write one post about God.” In this case, MacDonald not only makes some unabashed claims about God’s nature but also offers his characteristic prioritization of praxis/doctrine.

Human justice may be a poor distortion of justice, a mere shadow of it; but the justice of God must be perfect. We cannot frustrate it in its working; are we just to it in our idea of it? If you ask any ordinary Sunday congregation in England, what is meant by the justice of God, would not nineteen out of twenty answer, that it means his punishing of sin? Think for a moment what degree of justice it would indicate in a man—that he punished every wrong. A Roman emperor, a Turkish cadi, might do that, and be the most unjust both of men and judges. Ahab might be just on the throne of punishment, and in his garden the murderer of Naboth.

In God shall we imagine a distinction of office and character? God is one; and the depth of foolishness is reached by that theology which talks of God as if he held different offices, and differed in each. It sets a contradiction in the very nature of God himself. It represents him, for instance, as having to do that as a magistrate which as a father he would not do! The love of the father makes him desire to be unjust as a magistrate! Oh the folly of any mind that would explain God before obeying him! that would map out the character of God, instead of crying, Lord, what wouldst thou have me to do? God is no magistrate; but, if he were, it would be a position to which his fatherhood alone gave him the right; his rights as a father cover every right he can be analytically supposed to possess.

The justice of God is this, that—to use a boyish phrase, the best the language will now afford me because of misuse—he gives every man, woman, child, and beast, everything that has being, fair play; he renders to every man according to his work; and therein lies his perfect mercy; for nothing else could be merciful to the man, and nothing but mercy could be fair to him. God does nothing of which any just man, the thing set fairly and fully before him so that he understood, would not say, ‘That is fair.’

George MacDonald (from his sermon “Justice”, published in Unspoken Sermons, Series 3, 1889)

Google+ Comments

August 13th, 2012

Tags: , ,

  • http://twitter.com/jonestony Tony Jones

    Kind of cheating, but I’ll allow it!

  • http://www.facebook.com/justin.hanvey Justin Hanvey

    That is probably my most favorite sermon, one of the centerpieces to my eventual belief in Universal Reconciliation.

    • http://undeception.com/ Steve Douglas

      Definitely my favorite sermon ever. Possibly my favorite theological writing in general!